Chicago Knife Works has a customer service problem, and r/knives is keeping score. This week a user posting under the title "Yet Another Chicago Knife Works Victim" wrote that they ordered Ontario Rat parts, heard nothing for weeks, and only then searched Reddit, finding a long trail of similar reports. As of November 2026, the poster concluded the Illinois retailer was "likely just a huge scam," while noting they were luckily out only a small sum.
One Reddit thread is an anecdote. The pattern behind it is harder to dismiss. On Trustpilot, Chicago Knife Works holds an average of 1.5 stars across 112 reviews, and the recurring complaints are specific: shipping labels created weeks after payment, tracking numbers that never update, emails that go unanswered, and refunds promised in 7 to 10 business days that arrive in neither.

The Better Business Bureau file for the Morton Grove, Illinois company shows the same story in detail. A reviewer who placed three orders starting June 19, 2026 described waiting 40 days for the first delivery, then fighting to cancel the other two. Someone at the company emailed a cancellation and a refund timeline on July 30. By August 23 the reviewer reported $271.15 still owed. Other BBB complaints from the same summer describe a phone line that answers with a "down for repair" message, and one buyer who watched an order charged on May 30 sit with a label marked "awaiting item" into July.
They keep playing you off by printing more shipping labels but never ship the product that was already paid for 6 weeks ago.
The company has not gone quiet entirely. Its website banner currently reads that non-expedited orders are being processed within 5 to 7 business days due to increased order volume, and reviews name owner Mobeen Ashiq as someone who does step in when a public complaint forces the issue. That matches the pattern Trustpilot reviewers describe: silence until a chargeback or a public post, then sudden responsiveness.
What makes this worth a post in a knife forum rather than a shopping grumble is the pricing. Chicago Knife Works undercuts bigger retailers on a catalog of 30,000 items from more than 900 brands, and low prices are exactly what pulls buyers in before the fulfillment problems do. The practical advice from reviewers is consistent: pay with a card that supports chargebacks, screenshot everything, and treat a shipping label that has not scanned after a week as a refund request, not a delivery.
Until that changes, the discount is not worth the wait.